« back to The Forum - Journalism, insight and debate at the Frontline Club home


Digital Election 2010: social media's important, but not a kingmaker yet

| 1

MPs, Westminster hacks and activists might be addicted to expressing themselves in 140 characters or less, but don't expect this year's general election to be decided on which party has the best social media strategy.

But politicians and the media shouldn't dismiss voters' digital engagement either, according to a panel at a Frontline Club debate on the importance on social media on the upcoming election.

You can watch the whole thing here...
Live streaming video by Ustream 

Twitter certainly has the  potential to land politicians in mini-media storms though, as the  panelists agreed, if David Wright MP had merely told a reporter verbally that Conservatives are "scum" it's unlikely to have got much coverage, such is the continued novelty and of Twitter to many news editors.

Paul Staines, better known as mischevious Westminster blogger Guido Fawkes, argued that no matter how well connected parties are, with Labour, Conservatives and Lib Dems towing similar centerist policy lines  there was little to differentiate them for the ordinary voter: "If they are all marching in the centre ground, there's not much to market, is there?"

And as for reporters, they're "not going to get a scoop from Tweetdeck," he warned. "There are about 500 of us (in the Westminster village) listening to each other aren't there?"

Channel  4 News presenter Krishnan Guru-Murthy said social media buzz doesn't determine what C4 leads its 7pm bulletin with - but Twitter got the network's reporters in touch with someone in the audience at Nick Griffin's notorious Question Time performance."

But all this is missing the point, according to Chris Condron, Press Association's head  of digital strategy:

If you ask any journalist what they think about a phenomenon like Twitter... they tend to think about what it means for journalists, but where its potential really lies is for  audiences

The "disintermediation" of news - where readers can go straight to the source of news, such as an MP's Twitter stream - was  challenge for the media, but Condron is confident that the reporters' gathering and filtering of raw news was still essential."

  • Read the thoughts of Niall Paterson, Sky News reports and our moderator for the night.
    • And here are some choice tweets for the audience,,,

1 Comment

Anonymous | February 17, 2010 4:31 PM

The biggest issue is not how social media changes political communication or media reporting but how the public can use the internet or social media to access information about policy, politics or government 'performance'.