Reuters released the final video taken by Mr Shana in the seconds before his death. The footage shows a tank on a distant hilltop open fire. A tank shell is seen flying toward the camera followed by a large explosion before the screen went black. His car was marked "press" and witnesses said the cameraman was wearing an identifying flak jacket. link
« back to From the Frontline home
Fadel Shana buried in Gaza
on 17 Apr 2008 | 2
2 Comments
Vehicle stops, man gets out with something on his shoulder... young scared tank gunner and commander, probably tired and hot inside a 60-ton oven, think the camera is a shoulder launched weapon and open fire in the split second before they think the shoulder-launched weapon could be fired. Maybe they should get cameras that don't go on shoulders. As for "TV" markings on vehicles - have Palestinian militants never used vehicles marked for neutrality as cover? I know this is conjecture but I feel that the outrage at this poor chap's death is a little overblown.
This is what correpondents risk and unfortunately Mr Shana was unlucky.
From the Frontline:
Calendar
Recent posts
- Fukushima: in the shadow of the Semipalatinsk mushroom cloud by Lynne O'Donnell on April 30, 2011 5:54 AM
- Have our leaders learned nothing from the war in Afghanistan? by Lynne O'Donnell on April 18, 2011 12:07 PM
- Why the revolution should leave Midan Tahrir, for a moment at least by Julie Tomlin on April 15, 2011 10:33 AM
Categories
- About this blog (1)
- Advice for journalists (10)
- Afghanistan (136)
- Africa (112)
- Americas (42)
- Angola (1)
- Announcements (46)
- Asia-Pacific (64)
- Blogs (70)
- Bosnia (1)
- Brazil (2)
- Burma (47)
- Cambodia (9)
- Caribbean (1)
- Chad (6)
- China (25)
- Colombia (5)
- Congo (32)
- Croatia (2)
- Cuba (3)
- East Timor (1)
- Eating on the frontline (8)
- Egypt (2)
- Entertainment (49)
- Equatorial Guinea (1)
- Estonia (1)
- Europe (24)
- Fixers (12)
- Frontline Club magazine (5)
- Frontline bloggers (68)
- Frontline events (129)
- Frontline members (103)
- Frontline training (3)
- Future of journalism (53)
- Gaza (30)
- General (28)
- Get your kit out (17)
- Getting the story (101)
- Ghana (2)
- Guatemala (1)
- India (6)
- Indonesia (4)
- Iran (15)
- Iraq (173)
- Israel (20)
- Ivory Coast (4)
- Journalism (289)
- Journalism awards (55)
- Journalists in danger (289)
- Kenya (12)
- Kosovo (2)
- Lebanon (14)
- Liberia (2)
- Madagascar (2)
- Media attention (4)
- Mexico (6)
- Middle East (131)
- Nepal (1)
- Niger (3)
- Nigeria (4)
- North Korea (7)
- Obituary column (116)
- Pakistan (26)
- Palestine (7)
- Philippines (3)
- Photography (116)
- Romania (2)
- Russia (57)
- Rwanda (5)
- Saudi Arabia (2)
- Singapore (4)
- Somalia (78)
- Somaliland (1)
- South Ossetia (39)
- Sri Lanka (17)
- Sudan (16)
- Syria (3)
- Thailand (3)
- Transnistria (1)
- Transport (3)
- Tunisia (1)
- Turkey (2)
- Turkmenistan (1)
- UK (5)
- Uganda (6)
- Venezuala (3)
- Vietnam (6)
- War films (49)
- War words (68)
- Yemen (1)
- Zimbabwe (37)
Archives
Our Bloggers
- Adam Blenford on Photojournalism
Last update on 22/07/09 - Adam Pletts in Afghanistan
Last update on 10/02/11 - Alex Strick van Linschoten - a war reporter on the road
Last update on 16/12/09 - Ali S. Novruzov in Azerbaijan
Last update on 22/04/10 - Anastasia Moloney in Bogota
Last update on 23/12/08 - Anita Coulson in Africa
Last update on 04/04/08 - Ben Hammersley in the Philippines
Last update on 17/02/08 - Charlotte Cook on Documentary
Last update on 22/03/11 - Daniel Bennett - Reporting War
Last update on 31/03/11 - David Axe - Africa is Boring
Last update on 29/10/10 - David Gill in Afghanistan
Last update on 20/01/09 - Deborah Bonello in Mexico
Last update on 11/04/11 - Devjyot Ghoshal in India
Last update on 15/08/09 - Fred on the Democratic Republic of Congo
Last update on 30/10/08 - From War Zones to the Wilderness
Last update on 21/04/08 - Frontline Club on documentary films
Last update on 17/03/09 - Glenna Gordon in Liberia
Last update on 03/03/09 - Guy Degen in Germany
Last update on 18/02/11 - Heathcliff O'Malley - a photojournalist on the road
Last update on 03/02/09 - Hereward Holland in Accra
Last update on 23/02/11 - Hodan Yusuf-Pankhurst on Somalia
Last update on 12/02/11 - Iona Craig in Yemen
Last update on 15/03/11 - Isabelle Roughol about Cambodia
Last update on 26/10/09 - John Owen on international news reporting
Last update on 01/06/10 - Jonathan Gorvett in Borneo
Last update on 26/12/08 - Kevin German in Vietnam
Last update on 18/02/09 - Kyle MacRae on citizen journalism
Last update on 09/06/08 - Last week at the Frontline Club
Last update on 26/10/09 - Matthew Collin in Georgia
Last update on 01/09/10 - Michael O' Riordan in the United Arab Emirates
Last update on 10/12/08 - Mike Hills in Lebanon
Last update on 30/07/09 - Morten Hvaal a photojournalist on the road
Last update on 10/06/09 - Natalia Viana in Brazil
Last update on 15/09/09 - Olga Kravtsova on journalism and trauma
Last update on 28/12/10 - Oliver Balch in India
Last update on 30/01/10 - Onnik Krikorian in Armenia
Last update on 19/02/11 - Patrick Wells in West Africa
Last update on 29/10/10 - Pete Chonka on Somaliland
Last update on 26/06/10 - Peter Moszynski on Sudan
Last update on 03/03/09 - Phyza Jameel in Pakistan
Last update on 22/10/10 - Rob Crilly - African Safari
Last update on 21/06/10 - Ryan Gallagher on Journalism
Last update on 12/04/11 - Salam Pax in Baghdad
Last update on 11/03/09 - Sasa in Syria
Last update on 12/05/09 - The Forum - Journalism, insight and debate at the Frontline Club
Last update on 19/04/11 - Tom Finn in Yemen
Last update on 05/04/11 - Vaughan Smith in Afghanistan
Last update on 21/02/11 - Yawar Nazir and Abdul Mohamin Bhat in Kashmir
Last update on 15/05/09 - Zimbabaloola in Zimbabwe
Last update on 22/04/08
The commendable work undertaken by the Frontline Blogger to bring to our attention the daily deterioration of working conditions for foreign correspondents/journalists in the regions they report from is not enough.
This link to the Times Online website - a video of the final moments of a Palestinian reporter before being hit by Israeli fire - is the latest example of how indiscriminate acts by military forces are undermining this most noble of professions.
But in the grand scheme of things, this process of degrading the role of reporters in conflict zones is the least important consideration in light of the loss of life of people like Fadel Shana. To the conflict his death counts as just another piece of the collateral jigsaw puzzle, but in the cold light of day the world is a poorer place without him, or for that matter any other foreign correspondent lost on the frontline.
Surely the time has come to bring governments/military establishments to bear for these crimes. It would take a spectacular advocacy effort to get such events classified as war crimes, but some system of retrospective justice must be set in place for the victims of violence against the media. Without it, not only will the journalistic profession proceed along its current perrilous course, but justice for those who lost their lives will never be ensured.